Polar Ignite vs Grit X vs Vantage V compared

Withings Scanwatch vs Steel HR Sport vs Move ECG – Which is the Best?

Like this post? Share it to a friend...

The Scanwatch is the latest hybrid smartwatch from Withings, it was announced at the CES 2020. Although available in two sizes, it comes with a bigger and brighter PMOLED display, more durable sapphire glass covers the screen and is even more equipped to track sleep apnea, detects irregular heart rhythm and blood oxygen. The Scanwatch follows up on the Move ECG and Steel HR Sport in that order, and in this comparison we’re comparing the Withings Scanwatch vs Steel HR Sport vs Move ECG – What’s the difference and which of these three should you buy? Find out.

Withings Scanwatch vs Steel HR Sport vs Move ECG Specs Compared

 Withings Scanwatch (42mm)Withings Steel HR Sport
Withings Move ECG
withings scanwatch 42mmwithings steel hr sportwithings move ecg

EDITOR'S RATING

Design:
4.6 out of 5 stars (4.6 / 5)
Battery:
4.4 out of 5 stars (4.4 / 5)
Fitness tracking:
4.6 out of 5 stars (4.6 / 5)
Features:
3.3 out of 5 stars (3.3 / 5)
Price:
3.5 out of 5 stars (3.5 / 5)
Average:
4.1 out of 5 stars (4.1 / 5)
Design:
4.5 out of 5 stars (4.5 / 5)
Battery:
4.4 out of 5 stars (4.4 / 5)
Fitness tracking:
4.5 out of 5 stars (4.5 / 5)
Features:
3.8 out of 5 stars (3.8 / 5)
Price:
3.4 out of 5 stars (3.4 / 5)
Average:
4.1 out of 5 stars (4.1 / 5)
Design:
4.4 out of 5 stars (4.4 / 5)
Battery:
4.5 out of 5 stars (4.5 / 5)
Fitness tracking:
4 out of 5 stars (4.0 / 5)
Features:
3.1 out of 5 stars (3.1 / 5)
Price:
3 out of 5 stars (3.0 / 5)
Average:
3.8 out of 5 stars (3.8 / 5)

WHERE TO BUY

_<strong>Check @ Amazon</strong> Check @ Amazon Check @ Amazon

ABOUT DEVICE

Device nameWithings Scanwatch (42mm)Withings Steel HR SportWithings Move ECG
Device typeHybrid/Classic/Fitness
Hybrid/Classic/Fitness
Hybrid/Classic/Fitness
PredessesorWithings Move ECGWithings Steel HRWithings Move
Successor___
Released dateApril, 2020September, 2018September, 2019
Ideal forUnisexUnisexUnisex

DISPLAY

Display typeAnalog/PMOLED (monochrome)Analog/OLED (monochrome)Analog
Display size1.65 inch1.6 inch1.4 inch
Display resolution___
Pixel density___
Input typeSingle button
(Not touchscreen)
Single button
(Not touchscreen)
Single button
(Not touchscreen)
Always-onYesYesNone

BODY

ShapeCircularCircularCircular
Dimension42 x 42 x 13.7 mm40 x 40 x 13 mm38 x 38 x 13 mm
Weight83 grams49 grams32 grams
Casing materialStainless steelStainless steelStainless steel
Strap/band materialLeather
Silicone
Milanese mesh
Leather
Silicone
Leather
Silicone
Bezel MaterialStainless steelStainless steelStainless steel
Strap size20mm20mm18mm
Screen protectionSapphire glassCorning Gorilla GlassCorning Gorilla Glass
Water resistant/ProtectionYes, 5ATMYes, 5ATMYes, 5ATM
Swim-proofYes, recommendedYes, recommendedYes, recommended
Color(s)White, blackBlack
White
Silver
White/blue
White/black

MEMORY

RAM___
Internal storage___
Memory card slotNoNoNo

CONNECTIVITY

BluetoothBluetooth v5.0 LEBluetooth v4.0 LEBluetooth v4.0 LE
Bluetooth callingNoNoNo
Wi-FiNoNoNo
NFCNoNoNo
GPSNo (connected GPS)No (connected GPS)No (connected GPS)

CELLULAR TECHNOLOGY

TechnologyNoNoNo
SIMNoNoNo
BandNoNoNo

NOTIFICATIONS

Email alertYesYesNo
SMS alertYesYesNo
Calls alertYesYesNo
Event reminderYesYesNo
WeatherYesYesNo
Third-party appsYesYesNo

FITNESS TRACKING

Sleep apneaYesNoNo
Sleep trackingYesYesYes
StepsYesYesYes
Floors climbedYesNoYes
Heart rate monitoringYesYesYes
CaloriesYesYesYes
DistanceYesYesYes
StressNoNoNo
VO2 Max.YesYesNo
Blood oxygenYesNoNo
Blood pressureNoNoNo
Menstrual cycle trackingNoNoNo
Swim trackingYesYesYes
Under-water heart rate trackingNoNoNo
Preloaded mapsNoNoNo
On-screen workout modesNoNoNo
Triathlon modeNoNoNo
ECG TrackingYesNoYes
Preloaded sport modesYes, 30Yes, 30Yes, 30
Safety trackingNoNoNo

MEDIA

AudioNoNoNo
Music streamingNoNoNo
Bluetooth musicNoNoNo
RadioNoNoNo
LoudspeakerNoNoNo
MicrophoneNoNoNo
CameraNoNoNo

SENSORS

AccelerometerYesYesYes
Barometer/AltimeterYesNoYes
Heart rate monitor (HRM)YesYesYes
CompassNoNoNo
Gyroscope NoNoNo
Ambient lightYesYesNo
Pulse Ox.YesNoNo
ECGYesNoYes
ThermometerNoNoNo
Other sensors------

PLATFORM

Operating system (OS)___
Chipset___
CPUunknownunknownunknown
GPU------

BATTERY

Type of batteryNon-removable battery_Replaceable CR2430 button cell
Battery capacity 60mAh__
Battery lifeMixed usage:25 days+Standby: 20 days+
Mixed usage: 5 days+
Mixed usage: 11 Months+
Charging typeMagnetic charging cableMagnetic charging cableNo
Charging timeAbout 1-2 hrsAbout 1-2 hrsNo
Battery saver modeYesYesNo
Solar powerNoNoNo
Rapid chargingNo__

CLOCK FEATURES

Time/DateYesYesTime Only
StopwatchNoNoNo
AlarmYesYesYes

OTHER FUNCTIONS

Control cameraNoNoNo
Music controlNoNoNo
Find phoneNoNoNo
Text responseNoNoNo

MISC

Payment systemNoneNoneNone
Compatibility Android 6.0+,
iOS 12.0+
Android 6.0+,
iOS 10.0+
Android 6.0+,
iOS 10.0+
Companion appHealth Mate AppHealth Mate AppHealth Mate App
Customizable watch faceNoNoNo
Interchangeable band Yes, 20mmYes, 20mmYes, 18mm
Voice commandNoNoNo

BOX CONTENTS

Withings Scanwatch (42mm)Withings Steel HR SportWithings Move ECG
StrapsStrapsStraps
Magnetic chargerMagnetic charging cableCR2430 button cell
Quick start guideQuick start guideQuick start guide
NOTE: We can't guarantee that all the information on this table are 100% correct. Read full disclaimer. Please, report an error.
Official SiteOfficial SiteOfficial Site

The Difference?

Withings Scanwatch vs Steel HR Sport vs Move ECG Features Compared

  • Design

  • Each of these three watches from Withings is no doubt fine-looking, durably built and stylish. Perhaps some of the finest hybrid smartwatches on the market. Stainless steel has been used for the case on all three, while straps are available in leather and silicone, but are interchangeable just in case you wish to change it.

    Although each of these three has got a classy appearance, the Scanwatch is a higher-end device featuring more durable sapphire glass for the screen and also has a brighter and wider PMOLED display that’s a lot easier to read compared to the Steel HR Sport. The Move ECG lacks a digital display, but still got a smaller face that displays activity progress which is also present on the other two.

    The 32g and 38mm sized Move ECG weighs a little less than the other two and is the most compact. So, it’s the most comfortable wear.

  • Fitness Tracking

  • Each of these three is fitness-focused and equipped to track your active life, but the Scanwatch being more equipped is able to track more activities than you can with the Steel HR Sport or Move ECG. The Scanwatch is the first smartwatch from Withings with the capability to track sleep apnea – a health condition that can go undetected and can be fatal. This occurs as a result of insufficient airflow into the lungs which may cause a drop in blood oxygen level.

    Moreover, the Scanwatch and Move ECG feature ECG tracking which can help you detect irregular heart rhythm also known as atrial fibrillation (AFib), Steel HR Sport lacks this feature.

    Both the Scanwatch and Steel HR Sport come with about 30 preloaded sport modes from which you can easily select from your preferred workout mode. This isn’t possible with the Move ECG.

    Although, each of these three will track your steps, complete sleep cycle, outdoor activities via connected GPS and heart rate monitoring. You can then see your stats and manage your fitness goals through the Health Mate App.
    The table below shows the difference in activities tracked by these three.

     ScannwatchSteel HR SportMove ECG
    Complete Sleep Tracking

    Tracks sleep stages
    (light, deep and rem)
    YesYesYes
    Tracks Sleep Apnea

    During sleep, it can detect insufficient air flow into the longs which may cause a drop in blood oxygen level.
    YesNoNo
    Fitness level/VO2 Max.

    Accesses fitness level based on the maximal oxygen consumption.
    YesYesNo
    Connected GPS

    Connects to phone GPS to track your outdoor activities such as routes, pace, distance and location.
    YesYesYes
    Altimeter

    Has altimeter that can count floors climbed and display elevation data.
    YesNoYes
    ECG Tracking

    Allows you take ECG right from your wrist which can help you detect irregular heart rhythm known as atrial fibrillation (AFib) that may lead to stroke and heart failure when left untreated.
    YesNoYes
    Has SpO2 Sensor

    Tracks your blood oxygen.
    YesNoNo
    Heart Rate Tracking

    Tracks your heart rate continuously, shows heart rate zones and calories and can alert you of atypical heart rate.
    YesYesYes
    Preloaded Sport Modes

    Has preloaded sport modes that allow you choose your preferred workout mode.
    YesYesNo
    Display Daily Activity Goal

    Set a goal for the day, and the watch shows your progress for the day.
    YesYesYes

  • Notifications

The Move ECG which lacks digital display lacks the ability to display new notifications compared to the Scanwatch and Steel HR Sport which both have a small digital PMOLED display that lets you see new notifications from your phone.

  • Battery Life
  • The Move ECG uses a replaceable CR2430 button cell unlike the Scanwatch and Steel HR Sport both of which have a rechargeable battery. While the Move ECG will go about a year before needing battery replacement, the Steel HR Sport will go about 25 days long which is a little shorter than the Scanwatch with about 30 days long battery life.

    Verdict

    We have three fine classic hybrid smartwatches, fantastic design, nice activity tracking features and long battery life, but the Scanwatch with a more durable and stylish design and more health tracking features makes it the most comprehensive activity tracker, and is the best choice.

    On the other hand, the Steel HR Sport with notification ability even though lacks ECG tracking is a smarter alternative, while the Move ECG is still a nice choice if notification on your wrist matters less to you.

    Our Pick

    Although more expensive, the Scanwatch is our preferred choice. With stainless steel and sapphire glass, it’s a more durable smartwatch and with sleep apnea and ECG, it’s one of the most advanced health monitors on the market.

    Price

    Was this post helpful?

    Rate it!

    Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

    No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

    We are sorry that this post was not useful for you!

    Let us improve this post!

    Tell us how we can improve this post?

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *